"Love it!! Everyone is so nice and the pizza and garlic knots are amazing!! I work at the end of the plaza and have eaten here 3 days in a row now lol. It's so good!! Definitely recommend! :)"

"I don't usually write reviews but I had to say that this pizza is excellent. Even in PA, pizza was good but nothing close to NY pizza. Same down here most places are good but I have to say that this to me is like eating a New York slice of pizza, and I'm looking forward to trying some of their other menu items. Finally, thank you Richie, Wayne and the gang, keep up the good work, please!!!"

"Pizza was excellent, Calzone was world class!! You gotta try it, crispy on the outside, loaded with cheese (including ricotta) on the inside."

"This is the pizza I have been missing!!! No take out box needed at all. Cooked to perfection with zero extra instruction. The sauce was just like home! No canned product here. The staff was quick and friendly. Even scored a cannoli that was fresher than fresh and the perfect ending to a beautiful Jensen Beach day and meal with the girls."

"This establishment truly puts customer satisfaction first and always goes the extra mile to make things right. It's evident that they deeply appreciate their customers and are dedicated to ensuring a delightful dining experience. We encourage everyone to give this restaurant a try and show your support for a local business that truly values its patrons."

"We ordered in a Supreme and cheese pizza and it was DELICIOUS!!! Love the sweet sauce! The garlic knots melt in your mouth and taste so good!!! The person on the phone went out of his way to make sure we got cannolis and they were great!! So happy you’re on the island!!! Yum!!!"

"New York style pizza was awesome, the slices are huge! Fish tacos were brand new on the menu, they came out fresh and flavorful! Stop by and check them out!"

"The food was excellent. Large portions and a great price. 5 of us was $55.00. Probably the best pizza I've had in a long time."

"Hey yo! Just came down from some hard junk, and after I survived a massive undertow in the water (I lost a bet; had to buy my jerk friends some beer) I hopped over to Casa Italiano for a slice of pizza.  Awesome! If it wasn't for that pizza, my friends would have left me across the street, getting eaten up by sand fleas and mosquitoes. You're the best! Ciao."

"The ideal place to have a quick slice of pizza or two and an ice cold drink or to sit on the dining side in the cool air conditioning and be served by the great staff. 10/10The ideal place to have a quick slice of pizza or two and an ice cold drink or to sit on the dining side in the cool air conditioning and be served by the great staff. 10/10"

"The guys here are so cool, but most of all amazing New York style pizza. Nice thin crispy cheese slice super fresh"

"After reading all the great reviews we decided to try it out for ourselves. We loved the food. We tried the chicken francese and the veal parm. It was very good. We definitely will be coming back."

"The pizza is the best. We’ve had grandmas pie and BBQ chicken and both are incredible. Great cheesesteak Stromboli too!"

"Great food and service!"

"Pizza was outstanding. Totally had that NY pie taste! I highly recommend."

"Best NY style pizza I've had since I left NY! Support local small businesses"

"The seafood is excellent! We had the Mahi Mahi dinner and the Butter Burger. Best in the area"

"Delicious pizza, charismatic owner/staff and good prices for quality food 😊 😃 …"

"Best sub and garlic knits I have had in a long time! We will be back!"

 

"Good N.Y. style pizza. Good thin crust,great crunch."

 

"Great New York Style Pizza! Friendly service!"

"Awesome menu more than a slice. What a slice. This place hits the spot."

"Pizza is delicious and staff is friendly and accommodating!"

 

"Some of the best pizza in the area"

 

"By far, the best pizza within 30mi of Jensen Beach, maybe even further. This is authentic NY, NJ pizza."

"Wow!! Authenticity! Phillycheese sandwiches, calzone, and pizza !. You will feel like you are in Brooklyn!"

"Excellent fresh pasta. Delicious tomato sauce and Alfredo sauce too. We didn't taste the pizzas."